Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dylon Meissner's avatar

You can check the government page yourself, it claims Victoria has an average usage of 30gj. That was the only false part in my statement. You clearly didn't even check the links before getting defensive. The one retailer information suggests the average rural house in Alberta is 272gj. Which is even far more than 5x that of Vancouver.

These retailers quoted are just as qualified as a retailer in Ontario.

I proved exactly my point that you can use whatever statistics you want to create whatever truth you want. Which is in alignment of your original article about the carbon tax. They aren't lying about the numbers. They're just using the numbers they want to. Statistics never tell the truth. Ever. The numbers can, but statistics ALWAYS tell the story of the person who formed them.

Expand full comment
Dylon Meissner's avatar

Their math for natural gas is off, and it shows when you try to google the average usage. There are numerous websites and all of them are inconsistent. But one consistency is the Alberta average uses approximately 5x the amount of Vancouver. And 3x Southern Ontario. Considering those 2 areas are the most densely populated areas in Canada and consist more commonly of high density housing, which generally have less heat loss, it skews the average significantly. For example Vancouver still uses less than 1/3 of the national average because they don't see -40C. Once again, Vancouver and Southern Ontario speak for the entirety of Canada.

Carbon tax is set at $4. 095 per GJ, which will mean they determined the national average to be 80gj but I consistently found sites stating over 100gj. Which i still find low based on personal usage and I have a 900sf home with 2 people. And I have an electric water heater, not natural gas.

No matter how hard I try, I can't make their numbers line up.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts